The return of Carrie Underwood to American Idol as a judge for season 23 has sparked both excitement and debate. The country music star, who won the competition in 2005, joined the judging panel alongside Luke Bryan and Ryan Seacrest. However, her journey back to the show was not straightforward, and her future with the series remains unclear, according to a production insider cited by The U.S. Sun.
Videos by Wide Open Country
ABC executives considered several high-profile artists before selecting Underwood to replace Katy Perry. The insider revealed that Underwood "was not the network's first pick" for the role. Names like Pink, Miley Cyrus, and Meghan Trainor were in discussions, as confirmed by returning judge Luke Bryan in a Billboard interview. Even after Underwood's selection, the decision lacked unanimous support among producers and network executives.
Despite the rocky start, Underwood has brought emotional depth and nostalgia to the judging table. Her interactions with contestants resonate with fans, many of whom praise her as a "breath of fresh air." However, not all viewers are convinced. Some criticize her judging style, reflecting the divide that began during her casting.
Bryan acknowledged the challenge of filling Perry's shoes, telling Billboard, "Katy was really perfect for that job."
Will Underwood Stay or Go?
Underwood's future on American Idol remains uncertain. The insider noted that while early in the season, many assumed she would return for season 24, opinions have shifted. "Her Idol future is much more uncertain now than it was," the source said, adding that the uncertainty is mutual. Decisions about next season's judging panel are expected within the next month, with "nothing off the table."
The demanding filming schedule in Los Angeles may be a factor. The insider suggested Underwood, a mother of two, appears "miserable" being away from her family. Additionally, she may be reluctant to navigate the "Hollywood game" and network expectations. This has led to speculation that Underwood could be "one and done" as a judge.
Meanwhile, Perry has no plans to reclaim her seat. A source told The U.S. Sun that Perry views her time on Idol positively but has "graduated from that chapter." The grueling schedule was a key reason for her departure, and she now "feels more like herself," the source added.
A Polarizing Yet Impactful Presence
Underwood, 42, has undeniably left her mark on season 23. Fans who adore her highlight her authenticity and connection to the show's roots. Critics, however, remain unimpressed, echoing the initial reservations of some producers. As American Idol approaches decisions for season 24, all eyes are on whether Underwood will stay or step away from the spotlight she once claimed as a contestant.
